What are the most popular orders at Cook Out, according to various Reddit threads and sources? We’ve combined the results and comments!
Favorites from the Reddit crowd generally revolve around the value trays menu, which offer a combination of entrees, sides and drinks for an unbeatable price.
Across multiple Reddit threads, it’s clear that Cook Out’s menu is beloved for its variety and customization.
Whether it’s a classic Big Double burger, chicken strips, or a more adventurous combo with quesadillas and milkshakes, customers have found endless ways to enjoy their trays.
Most Popular Cook Out Orders (via Reddit)
The Big Double Burger Tray
This is consistently one of the most popular choices, featuring a Big Double Hamburger, often paired with sides like fries and hushpuppies.
Many people add a milkshake, with favorites like the Orange Push Up or Oreo milkshake, making this a top recommendation across Reddit forums.
One user shared: “Big Double burger, Cajun fries, and hush puppies with an Oreo shake is my go-to. It’s a massive meal for the price!”
Another added: “The Big Double with fries and hush puppies. You have to get the Orange Push Up milkshake – it’s a game-changer!”
Spicy Chicken Sandwich with Quesadillas or Chicken Strip Tray with Quesadillas
Another crowd-pleaser is the spicy chicken sandwich paired with quesadillas, offering a bit of a Tex-Mex flair. A milkshake like banana or chocolate often complements this combo according to Reddit readers.
A Redditor commented: “Spicy chicken sandwich with two quesadillas and a banana milkshake. Perfect mix of flavors and a ton of food.”
Another user added: “Always the spicy chicken sandwich, two quesadillas, and fries. The banana pudding milkshake goes so well with it!”
Many Reddit users also suggested ordering the Chicken Strip Tray, and adding quesadillas as sides for an extra indulgent meal.
A Reddit user commented: “I usually go for the chicken strip tray with quesadillas and Cajun fries. You can’t beat the value, and the strips are perfectly crispy.”
Another user added “Always the chicken strip tray, and the quesadilla is a must! Add a Cheerwine float, and you’re set!”
BBQ Tray
Cook Out’s BBQ options also garner significant love, with recommendations for the BBQ chargrilled chicken sandwich or regular barbecue plate, accompanied by hush puppies, coleslaw, and a Cheerwine float.
This Southern-style order is ideal for those looking for a classic, hearty meal.
One Reddit user wrote: “I always get the BBQ sandwich with hush puppies and slaw. If I’m feeling fancy, I’ll get a Cheerwine float, too.”
Another fan of the tray commented: “The BBQ tray is the best! Get it with coleslaw and a Cheerwine float for the ultimate Southern meal.”
Hot Dog Combo & Hot Dog Tray
For those seeking variety, trays with hot dogs and side combinations like onion rings or chicken nuggets are a hit. Pairing this with a chocolate milkshake or Cheerwine sweet tea completes the experience on advice from Reddit readers.
One user mentioned: “Two hot dogs, onion rings, and a chocolate milkshake. It’s my go-to when I want something lighter but still filling.”
Cook Out’s hot dogs are surprisingly popular, especially for those looking for a lighter meal with a variety of sides. A user mentioned: “Hot dog tray with chili and slaw, paired with hush puppies and a milkshake. Simple, but so satisfying!”
Cheddar Style Burger
The Cheddar Style Burger is a favorite for those who enjoy a loaded burger with a sharp cheese flavor.
One Redditor shared: “My go-to is the Cheddar Style burger with bacon and onions, Cajun fries on the side. It’s the perfect burger for when you want something hearty.”
Quesadilla & Onion Rings Combo
Some users go for the Tex-Mex approach, building their tray around quesadillas and pairing them with crispy onion rings.
A Reddit user explained: “Quesadilla and onion rings, always. It’s a weird combo, but the crunch from the rings with the cheesy quesadilla is unbeatable.”
Another edditor wrote: “I go with the chicken quesadilla, onion rings, and Cheerwine. It’s my weird combo, but it hits the spot every time.”
Another agreed, saying: “Chicken quesadilla with hush puppies and onion rings. It’s the perfect mix of crunch and cheesy goodness.”
Milkshake Variety
Cook Out’s milkshakes receive almost universal praise, with flavors like Oreo, Banana, and Orange Push-Up frequently mentioned.
One user shared: “The Orange Push-Up milkshake is a game changer, especially with the spicy chicken sandwich. Sweet and spicy is the way to go!”
“The Oreo milkshake is a classic, but I always switch it up,” another added. “Banana pudding and Reese’s are also super good.”
Another user wrote: “I can’t go to Cook Out without getting a Reese’s milkshake. It’s thick, creamy, and full of peanut butter flavor.”
Cajun-Style Fries with Any Tray
Cajun fries are a huge hit, often recommended by Reddit users as a go-to side to elevate any tray.
One Redditor said: “You have to get the Cajun fries with any tray! They’re spicy, crunchy, and better than the regular ones. Add a side of ranch, and you won’t regret it!”
Another user chimed in: “Cajun fries for the win. I’ll get them with my BBQ tray or even just with a milkshake. So addictive.”
Chicken Wraps
For those looking for something lighter, the chicken wraps are a popular choice. A Reddit user mentioned: “Chicken wrap tray with fries and hush puppies. It’s cheaper than most combos, and you still get a ton of food!”
Another user shared: “I love the grilled chicken wraps—they’re filling, but not too heavy. Perfect with a banana shake.”
The BBQ Sandwich
The BBQ sandwich is a must-try for lovers of Southern barbecue. A fan shared their favorite tray: “Always go for the BBQ sandwich with hush puppies and slaw. It’s such a good Southern meal, and you can’t beat the price.”
Another commented with their preference: “BBQ sandwich, slaw, fries, and sweet tea. Cook Out has some of the best fast food BBQ I’ve had.”
Corn Dog as a Side
Adding a corn dog as a side is a unique way to switch things up at Cook Out!
One user said: “Corn dog and fries as sides with my cheeseburger tray. I feel like a kid again every time I order it.”
Another added: “It’s weird, but I always get a corn dog and a quesadilla. The best comfort food!”
Sweet Tea & Cheerwine Floats
Cook Out is known for its sweet tea and Cheerwine floats, often mentioned in Reddit discussions.
One Redditor praised: “Sweet tea is an essential. I’ll get it with any tray I order. Sometimes I mix it with lemonade for a quick Arnold Palmer.”
Another fan of the Cheerwine float said: “A Cheerwine float with hush puppies? Yes, please. It’s the perfect mix of sweet and savory!”